Skip to main content

hog island's bbq oyster recipe

To make a meal all that more special Benjamin likes to add oysters.  He loves them raw but barbecuing them works too.  I enjoyed my last oysters in the early weeks of pregnancy before I knew I was pregnant at Early Mountain Vineyards for their Oyster Fest.  They were delicious and I enjoyed each one knowing they could be my last.

Now, I don't have a taste for them but Benjamin still does.  Each time we're in Wegmans he has to go check them out, ask how fresh they are, and talk about getting a few.  It doesn't usually happen so when it does he comes up with fun sauces to go atop them or this time he turned to Hog Island's BBQ oyster recipe.

We spent a wonderful day at Hog Island Oyster Company in California on our honeymoon.  It's a day I'd like to do again, maybe especially because we drove right through Pt. Reyes Station and now I hear about how adorable that little town is and really about the amazing cheese we could have filled up on from Cypress Grove.  Oh how I love Humboldt Fog.

We can't go back though- at least not til we have some serious savings to do so- but for now we can recreate a part of what we had.  Here's to oysters- fresh, shucked, and barbecued.

Ingredients You'll Need
  • 1/2 cup extra-virgin olive oil
  • 1/4 pound unsalted butter
  • 1 tablespoon chopped garlic
  • 1/4 tablespoon red chili flakes
  • 1/4 cup chopped shallots
  • 1/4 cup chopped red bell pepper
  • 1/2 cup chopped parsley
  • a dozen oysters
Combine everything but the oysters in a saucepan and let simmer over low heat for about 15 minutes.  

Spoon sauce over shucked oysters in their shell and barbecue for about 5 minutes then serve immediately.  Enjoy- best with a glass of wine!


  1. Anonymous9/19/2013

    Quick note: Dont over cook the oysters! Some grills are really hot! A hot grill is ok, but you just want the oysters to simmer in their own juices for a few min. The meat will simmer and bubble on the edges and ture a little white. If over cooked they will be rubbery and chewy. This is the perfect way to enjoy oysters if the idea of eating raw seafood doesn't sit well with you. Done right, this recipe will add complexity but preserve the fresh nature of a good oyster. Also if the oysters arn't so fresh this is my perfered way of peperation.

    - Bennythebrewer

  2. Anonymous9/19/2013

    O and go easy on the sauce, no need to cover anything up, just enhance!

    - Bennythebrewer


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Guest Post: New Mom (Anytime) Gift Guide

Today's Guest Post is from Michelle Perez of Simply Complicated.  I met Michelle in college and since then she has gotten hitched, had a baby, and lives in Guatemala where her family are doing some great work.  Read more on her blog and until then, check out her gift guide for new moms!  Thanks, Michelle!

I am a new mom to and am still very much in the ups and downs of learning how to how to take care of a very small human and myself. Even though I think all new moms would be happy with a nap, a long shower and a meal on their doorstep I have put together a gift guide that stretches a bit beyond the basic. You could say this is just in time for the holidays, but the truth is, this is an anytime of year gift guide. Enjoy.

1. Sugar & Spice Kitchen Towels We all know new moms like and appreciate home cooked meals. But I was surprised as a nursing mom, how hungry I was all. the. time. Friends of mine were so sweet, because they brought over a meal AND muffins or bread or baked goods …

quesadilla pie

This is a dinner I've been thinking about and trying to figure out when I'll make it next.  It'll probably happen sometime this weekend because it was simple and oh-so-satisfying.  It was a perfect new-mom meal. New-Mom as in I had time to make it, and I'd like to bring it to new mom's too.

I'm tempted to even make a few and stock my freezer with them for when we're hungry or when I need to bring someone a meal, a task I think I'm finally now up for seeing as I've been able to figure out our schedule more and get back in the kitchen.

Apart from pulling apart the chicken this dish comes together really quickly.  The original recipe calls for 1/3 cup chopped pickled jalapenos, an item I thought we had in our fridge but it turns out what I thought were pickled jalapenos were actually molding olives.  Not so great.  Next time I'll add in the jalapenos but they're definitely optional.

So this weekend, you should make this.  Dare I say my mouth i…

canned tomato sauce with basil and garlic

When I think about canning I want to make things that I'll use year round.  I want staples that I can go to that'll make pasta sauce, chili and stuffed peppers that much more delicious.  I want to make a recipe that tastes amazing in large part because the tomatoes used in it were fresh in the summer then preserved.
Although I did can some tomatoes last summer I ended up not using them as often as I thought I would.  I still found myself going to the store for diced tomatoes here and there when I should have been in the mindset to use my canned tomatoes and just crush them into the recipe.  Canning fail.

So, this year I decided to make some sauce.  It was an all day affair, let me tell you, but worth it in the end.  I looked to the Ball website for canning recipes and used their recipe for tomato sauce with basil and garlic.  You can see the original recipe here.  
I did tweak it some.  I didn't strain the sauce but rather pureed it in the Vitamix which really did away wi…